Don’t blame Russian bots for conspiracy theories on social media – we spread them ourselves

Author

Dave Hahnhttps://davehahn.substack.com/
Dave Hahn recently defended his PhD dissertation this past November the title of which is “Appeal to Conspiracy: A Philosophical Analysis of the Problem of Conspiracy Theories and Theorizing. He is an adjunct professor at SUNY Geneseo where he teaches a conspiracy theory and skepticism course and lives in Buffalo, NY.
spot_img

More from this author

spot_img

Recently, the Ukrainian Army bombed a Russian Data Center. There were a few effects of this attack. Notably it exposed how vulnerable Russia’s “Sovereign Internet” was to attack. Another reported effect was the decline in Russian disinformation, as the source of their network of bots prompting Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy to comment:

It suddenly became a little easier to breathe on many social media platforms. There was less hate, less division and fewer provocations.

Zelenskyy’s comment doesn’t stand up to scrutiny, but it seems like it should. This site has published on Russian disinformation before, I myself have pointed it out, and we know that Russian troll farms had their hand in influencing the Brexit referendum and the US 2016 presidential election. Zelenskyy’s claim is war propaganda reassuring his supporters that his resistance to Russian invasion is in everyone’s best interest.

The words of Zelenskyy’s comment though struck me even though the meaning is without evidence. Would there be less hate, less division, and fewer provocations if Russian bots were not spreading disinformation and conspiracy theories through the internet? That’s a question that I can answer.

The more tech savvy of you can probably look at metrics, data, and positronic networks (those are things right?) to discover a quantitative relationship between bots and conspiracy claims. I cannot do that, because it’s all just data to me. Instead, I will look at the relationship between conspiratorial ideation, stress or paranoia, and social media – this is the vector of infection and, if there is a relationship, we have established a hypothesis that all of you data people can then test with your fancy math data.

A photograph of racks of computers networked together in a data centre
More data centres, more conspiracies? Image: Taylor Vick, Unsplash

First, we have to define some terms: conspiracism is the pathological belief in conspiracy theories about the world. A conspiracist is a person who then behaves in this manner. Take, for example, the murder of real-life internet troll Charlie Kirk. We have an alleged shooter for whom evidence supports his role in the murder, but we have a vast network of conspiracy theorists who claim everything from ‘second shooter’ to exploding lapel microphones. Instead of the shooter who confessed to his significant other, parent, and pastor, we get allegations involving his widow, the vice president, and Reptoids (probably).

Part of skepticism, for me, has been attempting to figure out how someone goes from a seemingly rational position to the bottom of the conspiracist well. There are a few theories that explain this, and I’ve written about them previously: one is that you get hoodwinked into believing the big theories, because you believed in the little ones first. Another motivation is that a person feeling lost in the vastness of humanity wants to stand out, so they begin believing in the unusual or fantastic. Or perhaps a lonely individual is just looking for a community, and they stumble into a conspiracy theorist world where they not only find themselves in that community, but they can stand out as well.

A fourth reason is stress. Stress is an evolutionary response to a threat. Stress makes us worried about things related to our well-being. Stress is also connected to our instinct for pattern recognition. The clichéd example is: if a bush rustles and Ooog the Neanderthal gets mauled by a tiger leaping from it, others begin to associate the movement of the bush with tigers. It’s not just that; they also become nervous around moving bushes. It becomes programmed in, because the people that have this response survive, and those that do not, well, do not. Those that survive teach others to beware of rustling bushes.

Someone with little stress isn’t hunting for patterns, whereas someone under a high amount of stress will see them more frequently. This fuels the acceptance of conspiratorial ideation, according to Swami et al. (2016). They argue that some people under a great deal of stress will view the world’s events as unpredictable and chaotic; these individuals will then seek out conspiracy theories because:

By simplifying and by linking a series of events in relation to its supposed causes and effects, conspiracy theories may offer seeming coherent explanations for distressing phenomena.

In lay terms, individuals drawn to conspiracism may find an appeal in the world having a purpose and an order to it. This is counterintuitive, because that order comes from a malevolent hidden hand that cannot be stopped. A conspiracy theory alleging that the Covid-19 pandemic was caused by a lab leak in Wuhan is trying to offer an explanation that references an order to the world. X wasn’t the result of random chance; it was the result of an order that broke down.

With this relationship established, we need to identify a possible source for stress: social media. Social media has a definite positive relationship to stress levels. Du et al. (2024), provide a comprehensive study displaying a link between problematic social media use (PSNU) and four specific types of anxiety (generalised anxiety, social anxiety, attachment anxiety, and fear of missing out). Hill (2026), argues that it’s the type of engagement, not social media qua social media. Suthaharan and Corlett (2023), argue that social media networks provide for communities of conspiracy theorists which support their paranoia and sustain conspiratorial belief.

Literature investigating the link between social media and anxiety is vast and varied. Yet, I cannot find an article that refutes the general link. There are a few which will claim some benefit, but even Skeggs and Orben (2025), claim that social media use can be beneficial specifically when used in a structured, purposeful manner.

General or mindless social media use is the problem, as most of us are not engaging with social media with direction and structure in mind. We’re doomscrolling on the couch, and this is where Zelenskyy’s claim makes such intuitive sense. Social media use increases feelings of paranoia, stress, and anxiety, which in turn create adherence to conspiracy theories. Conspiracy theories foster division, fear, anger, and hate. Those feelings increase stress and anxiety; and thus the cycle continues.

While Ukraine’s attacks on Russian data centres didn’t impact the legions of internet bots spreading Russian misinformation, it did shine a light on an effect that we’re all kind of aware of social media having on us.

The Skeptic is made possible thanks to support from our readers. If you enjoyed this article, please consider taking out a voluntary monthly subscription on Patreon.

spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest articles

More like this